Are substitute teachers W-2 employees or 1099 contractors? What the IRS test looks at, and what to do if a staffing agency sends you a 1099
It depends on how the work is run, not on the form you were sent. The IRS says that, under the common law rules, "a worker is an employee if the firm has the right to control and direct what will be done and how it will be done." A contract that calls you an independent contractor does not settle it. In two rulings the IRS has published, substitute teachers had been paid on Form 1099-MISC, and both times the IRS concluded they were employees. Staffing agencies differ. Kelly Education says its substitutes are W-2 employees, and the Senya platform says it does not employ substitutes at all. If you think you were paid on the wrong form, the IRS has two forms for it. Form SS-8 asks it for a ruling, and Form 8919 lets you pay the employee's share of Social Security and Medicare tax rather than the self-employed rate.
The federal test is the same in every state. Your state runs its own test for unemployment and wage law, and some are stricter, so the sections below include California and Illinois. We read every page cited here on November 18, 2026. This is not tax or legal advice. The IRS decides your federal status, your state's labor or unemployment agency decides it for state purposes, and a tax professional can tell you what to file.
What the IRS test looks at
The IRS groups the evidence into three categories on its page Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee?:
- Behavioral: "Does the company control or have the right to control what the worker does and how the worker does his or her job?"
- Financial: "Are the business aspects of the worker's job controlled by the payer?" That covers who pays for supplies, how you are paid, and whether you can make a profit or take a loss.
- Type of relationship: written contracts, employee-type benefits, whether the relationship will continue, and whether the work is a key part of the business.
No single factor decides it. The right to control counts even when nobody uses it. The label in your agreement carries little weight. In an SS-8 ruling on a substitute teacher, the IRS wrote that "it is the actual working relationship that is controlling and not the terms of the contract (oral or written) between the parties."
Form SS-8 itself shows what the IRS asks about a job. Its behavioral control questions include "Who gives the worker work assignments?" and "Who determines the methods by which the assignments are performed?" Reading the form is a quick way to see your own job the way the IRS would.
Two IRS rulings on substitutes paid on a 1099
The IRS publishes its SS-8 determinations for public inspection with identifying details removed. We read two that concern substitute teachers.
A worker asked. In one ruling, a substitute teacher worked for a firm that provides special education services from January 2017 until December 2018 and "received a 1099-MISC for both tax years." The firm argued the worker was a contractor because the worker "provided services as needed and could provide similar services as a substitute teacher to other firms." The firm paid an hourly wage. The worker said they were given a laptop and supplies, were supervised daily, and had a written evaluation every 3 months. The IRS concluded the worker "was a common law employee, and not an independent contractor operating a trade or business." It added that classification as a contractor "should not be based primarily on the fact that a worker's services may be used on a temporary, part-time, or as-needed basis."
A firm asked. In another, an education company that places substitutes with schools and homeschooling families requested the ruling because "the Arizona Department of labor was challenging the classification" of its substitutes, whom it had paid on Form 1099-MISC. Assignments went out by e-mail, the workers were paid $100 per day, they brought their own pens, pencils and teaching supplies, and the contract had a non-compete clause. The IRS found them employees. It noted that "A worker is free to accept or decline a work assignment" and that "The workers are licensed teachers, therefore would not have to be 'instructed' on how to perform their services," and it still concluded the firm had the right to direct and control the work.
Those two facts matter to subs. Choosing which jobs to take, and not needing to be told how to teach, did not make these workers contractors. But a ruling is not a rule for everyone. The IRS's instructions for Form SS-8 say "A determination letter applies only to a worker (or a class of workers) requesting it." Your facts would be weighed on their own.
Ready to stop refreshing?
Set your filters once. Sub Hero watches Frontline for you.
Start Free — No Card NeededWhat staffing agencies say about how they pay subs
Agencies publish their own answers, and they are not all the same.
- Kelly Education says: "substitute teachers employed through Kelly Education are W-2 employees — not contractors."
- Swing Education tells subs that "you may be working as an independent contractor or as an employee of your substitute company, like Swing."
- Senya says "Senya does not employ substitute teachers" and describes itself as "a technology platform designed for freelance substitutes to access job opportunities."
Before your first job through an agency or app, ask in writing which form it will send you in January. If it says 1099, ask who sets your rate, who gives you assignments, and who you report to at the school. Keep the answers. They are the facts an SS-8 asks for.
What changes between a W-2 and a 1099
On a W-2, your employer withholds tax and pays its own share of Social Security and Medicare. On a 1099, nothing is withheld and you pay both halves yourself. The IRS says "The self-employment tax rate is 15.3%," made up of 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare, and that you owe it if your net earnings from self-employment were $400 or more. Form 8919 figures an employee's share at 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare, or 7.65% in all.
A 1099 also means you report the income on Schedule C, the form for profit or loss from a business. Our post on tax deductions for substitute teachers covers expenses. If your district pays into a retirement plan instead of Social Security, see our post on the 7.5% plan.
Unemployment is decided by your state, and a 1099 does not end the question. The Illinois Department of Employment Security says a "1099 employee" is not synonymous with "independent contractor" as defined by its Unemployment Insurance Act, and that a worker "can qualify for regular UI benefits if IDES determines he or she is covered under Illinois law." California's Employment Development Department uses the ABC test, under which "The individual is considered an employee unless all three conditions are met." One of the three is that the individual "performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business." For summer and break claims, see our post on reasonable assurance. To find your own state's test, search your state unemployment agency's site for "independent contractor."
What to do if an agency sends you a 1099
- Ask the agency first. It may have sent the wrong form. If you got both a W-2 and a 1099 from the same agency and the 1099 amount should have been wages, Form 8919 has a separate reason code for that, and you do not file an SS-8.
- Ask the IRS for a ruling. File Form SS-8. The instructions say "There is no fee," and that the IRS sends blank SS-8 forms to the other parties, so the agency will be asked for its side. The IRS says "it may take at least six months to receive a determination." Include copies of every 1099 and W-2 for the years you are contesting.
- File your return on time anyway. The instructions say "Do not delay filing your tax return in anticipation of an answer to your Form SS-8 request."
- Use Form 8919 at tax time. Form 8919 is for workers who "were an employee but were treated as an independent contractor." If you have filed an SS-8 and not heard back, the form says to use reason code G and to file the SS-8 "on or before the date you file your tax return." It also warns that code G "isn't a guarantee that the IRS will agree," and that if it does not, "you may be billed for the additional tax, penalties, and interest."
- Watch the refund deadline. The SS-8 instructions say a refund claim is generally due within 3 years of filing the original return or 2 years of paying the tax, whichever is later, and that "Filing Form SS-8 does not prevent the expiration of the time in which a claim for a refund must be filed." They describe a protective Form 1040-X for that case.
One limit applies to subs hired by a public district. The SS-8 instructions say the IRS does not issue a determination letter for state or local government workers who may be covered by a Section 218 agreement, and that "Only the Social Security Administration (SSA) makes Section 218 Agreement determinations." Those workers are told to contact their State Social Security Administrator.
What we can't tell you
- Whether you are an employee. The IRS decides that for federal tax, and your state agency decides it for unemployment and wage law, from your facts.
- How the IRS rules on substitutes in general. We read two published rulings, not every one, and each applies only to the worker or class of workers that asked.
- Whether an agency's policy is the same today as when we read it, or the same in every state where it works. Ask the agency for yours.
- Which forms you should file. A tax professional or the IRS can answer that for your return.
Learn more: app.getsubhero.com
Plans start at $6.99/month. Works with Frontline Absence Management.