Sub Hero Blog

Tips and strategies for substitute teachers

← Back to Blog

How does a substitute get on a teacher's preferred list in Frontline, and can a sub see the feedback teachers leave?

Published: November 18, 2026

Someone else puts you there. A substitute cannot apply to a preferred list in Frontline. A teacher adds you to their own list, or an administrator adds you to a school, regional or district list, and none of the Frontline help pages we read say the substitute is told. Feedback works the same way. If your district has turned on Frontline's feedback feature, a teacher can rate a sub from 1 to 5 stars after an absence. Frontline's substitute help guide shows a sub how to leave feedback of their own and review it, but it describes no screen for feedback left about you. Whether you ever see it is your district's decision.

So if you have worked a few jobs and heard nothing, Frontline has not told you anything, good or bad. The sections below quote Frontline's help guides for teachers and for subs, a Frontline blog post written for administrators, and one staffing agency's published policy. We read every page cited here on November 18, 2026. Your district sets these features up, so its sub coordinator or HR office can tell you how they work where you sub.

Who can put you on a preferred list

Frontline's older help page Preference Lists, from the system's AESOP days, says "Substitutes can be placed on preference lists at four different levels on the system." It names them: a district list, a region or school grouping list, an individual school list, and a worker list, which belongs to one teacher or staff member. It also says "A substitute can be placed on more than one preference list." The page walks an administrator through adding names. It describes no way for a substitute to add themselves.

The teacher's own list is the one most subs mean. Frontline's employee help guide, written for teachers, says "Your district may have given you the ability to select a list of the subs you prefer to fill your absences." The teacher searches for a sub by last name and adds them. The guide adds, "We recommend not picking many more than five." So a teacher's list is short by design, and whether teachers have one at all is up to the district.

What being on a list does

A list sets the order in which subs hear about a job. The employee guide says "Aesop will attempt to contact these subs first when you create an absence." Aesop is the system's older name, and the guides still use it.

A teacher can also mark up to five subs on that list as favorites, which the guide calls the Favorite Five. Favorites who are "qualified and available" get an email as soon as the teacher creates an absence that needs a sub. The guide also says "Aesop will begin calling the Favorite Five subs during the next evening calling period up to 120 nights before the absence."

For the other levels, the Preference Lists page says the system "works from the 'bottom up.'" Subs on a school's list "most likely receive a call from AESOP before a substitute on the highest level," and subs on a teacher's list "would be the first called when this particular employee registers an absence."

Some districts also hold a preferred-list job back from everyone else for a set time before it opens up. Our post on excluded lists covers that setting, called Job Visibility, and why it can make jobs at one school seem to vanish.

Can you tell whether you are on one?

Not from any Frontline page we found. None of the help guides we read say a substitute is notified when added to, or dropped from, a teacher's list, a favorites list or a school list. The closest thing to a sign is in the teacher's guide: a favorite who is qualified and available gets an email when that teacher creates an absence. The guide does not say what that email contains, so it does not settle the question either.

Being dropped from a preferred list is not the same as being put on an excluded list, though from the sub's side the two can look alike. The excluded-list post explains the difference, and this one covers who can remove a sub from a booked job.

Ready to stop refreshing?

Set your filters once. Sub Hero watches Frontline for you.

Start Free — No Card Needed

What feedback Frontline collects on subs

Feedback is an optional feature. Frontline's employee guide to feedback says "If your district has opted to use this feedback feature, you will see a Feedback tab at the top of your home page." The tab lists absences from the past 14 days. The teacher picks one and gives "a 1 to 5 star rating with 1 star meaning their performance was 'poor' and 5 stars meaning it was 'outstanding'." Then the teacher answers a list of questions, and the district writes some of them. Once the feedback is submitted, "you will not be able to go back in and edit it."

Frontline's blog post The Value of Providing Feedback for Substitutes, written for school administrators, says the system "can automatically remind employees to leave feedback for substitutes." It argues for collecting feedback in the system rather than by email, because with email "you won’t have much visibility as an administrator into which substitutes are doing well."

Can a substitute see it?

Frontline's help guides do not describe a way. The substitute help guide has its own Feedback page, under the same district opt-in. It lets a sub give an overall star rating for an absence and answer questions about the experience. Afterward, it says, "you can review the feedback for all jobs in the current school year." The only list it names is "Feedback that I left," which is the sub's own feedback. The page has no tab for feedback left about you.

The teacher's side works differently. The employee guide says "If your district has given you the permission to see this feedback you will see the tab Feedback left for me," meaning the feedback subs left about their assignments. So in Frontline's guides, a teacher may be allowed to read what a sub wrote, and the sub's guide shows no matching view.

Frontline's own advice leaves room for the district to share it. The same blog post tells administrators that when teachers document a sub's performance, they should "make sure that it’s made available for the substitute to see." It does not say how. Each district seems to decide this for itself. The software does not show it to every sub.

If you sub through an agency

Staffing agencies publish their own policies. Swing Education, for one, tells schools on its site that if a sub exceeded expectations, they can "Add them to your ‘favorites’ so that you can request your preferred subs time and time again." On feedback, Swing's sub blog says its Response and Resolution Team reviews positive and unfavorable feedback about requests and follows up with subs, and that "Any negative feedback stays between you and the RRT." Other agencies have their own rules. Ask yours what schools can see about you and what you can see about them.

What to ask, and whom

Frontline leaves both answers to the district, so ask the district. The sub coordinator or HR office, or your agency if you work through one, can tell you:

Ask by email if you want the answer in writing. A teacher's list is that teacher's to manage, so only that teacher can say whether they would ask for you again.

What we can't tell you

Where Sub Hero fits

Sub Hero cannot put you on a preferred list, cannot tell you whether you are on one, and cannot see feedback. It works from the jobs your own Frontline login shows, so a job held for a preferred list reaches you when Frontline opens it to you, not before. When a job matching your filters appears, it sends an alert by email and push within seconds of it matching, and on Pro it can accept the job for you. It cannot win a job someone else booked first.

Learn more: app.getsubhero.com

Plans start at $6.99/month. Works with Frontline Absence Management.

Catch the Jobs You'd Actually Say Yes To

Set your filters once. Get notified the moment a matching job posts — and let Pro accept it before it's gone.

Start Free — No Card Needed
← Back to all posts